Header image  
line decor
line decor


Masters of Violence
Plantation Overseers of Eighteenth-Century Virginia, South Carolina, and Georgia

Tristan Stubbs

From trusted to tainted, an examination of the shifting perceived reputation of slave overseers

In eighteenth-century North America, major slaveowners typically hired overseers to manage their plantations. In addition to cultivating crops, managing slaves, and dispensing punishment, overseers were expected to maximize profits through increased productivity—often achieved through violence and cruelty. In Masters of Violence, Tristan Stubbs offers the first book-length examination of eighteenth-century overseers—from recruitment and dismissal to their relationships with landowners and enslaved people, as well as their changing reputations, which devolved from reliable to untrustworthy and incompetent.

At the beginning of the eighteenth century, slaveowners regarded overseers as reliable enforcers of authority; by the end of the century, particularly after the American Revolution, plantation owners viewed them as incompetent and morally degenerate, as well as a threat to their power. Through a careful reading of plantation records, diaries, contemporary newspaper articles, and many other sources, Stubbs uncovers the ideological shift responsible for tarnishing overseers' reputations.

In Masters of Violence, Stubbs argues that this shift in opinion grew out of far-reaching ideological and structural transformations to slave societies in Virginia, South Carolina, and Georgia throughout the Revolutionary era. Seeking to portray their own actions as positive and yet simultaneously distance themselves from slavery, plantation owners blamed overseers as incompetent managers and vilified them as violent brutalizers of enslaved people.

Tristan Stubbs is an affiliate faculty member of the Carolina Lowcountry and Atlantic World Program at the College of Charleston. He previously held appointments with the University of Oxford and the University of Sussex. Stubbs was the Gilder Lehrman Fellow at the Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, the Andrew W. Mellon Fellow at the Virginia Historical Society, and the Lewis P. Jones Visiting Fellow at the University of South Carolina. He earned his Ph.D. from the University of Cambridge.

“In this wonderfully sensitive study of plantation overseers in the eighteenth-century American South, Tristan Stubbs explains how these key intermediaries between profit-minded but paternalistic slave owners and brutalised enslaved people negotiated porous boundaries of dependency and autonomy. Masters of Violence is a major achievement, restoring the issue of class to societies riven by racial conflict.” — Trevor Burnard, University of Melbourne

“Based on a detailed reading of overseers’ letters and diaries, plantation journals, employer’s letters, and newspapers, Tristan Stubbs has traced the evolution of the position of the overseer from the colonial planter’s partner to his most despised employee. This deeply researched volume helps to reframe our understanding of class in the colonial and antebellum South.” — Tim Lockley, University of Warwick





6 x 9
256 pages
5 b&w illus.
ISBN 978-1-61117-884-5
Hardcover, $44.99s

ISBN 978-1-61117-885-2
Ebook $44.99
Carolina Lowcountry and Atlantic World
David Gleeson, Simon Lewis, and John White, series editors

    Copyright ©2019 The University of South Carolina Press