3. Appeal to the Department
Chair Level Two
a. If the course or clerkship director's decision is not favorable to the student, the student' clerkship director's decision.
i. For departmentally based courses, the student may appeal the course or clerkship director's decision to the department chair.
ii. For team-taught courses, the student may appeal the course or clerkship director's decision to the department chair responsible for management of the course.
iii. The appeal must be made within 10 days of receiving the decision from the course or clerkship director.
b. After consultation with the course or clerkship director, the department chair may uphold the director's decision or support the student appeal. Should the department chair determine that there is a reason to change the course grade or evaluation in the student's favor, the department chair will send a request for revision to the School of Medicine Registrar, who will in turn take the request to the Grade Change Committee. If no reason for change is found, the chair will inform the student that the grade or evaluation stands. In either event, the student must receive written notification of the department chair's decision within ten working days of the student?s appeal.
4, Appeal to the Grade Change Committee Level Three
a. If the student is dissatisfied with the decision of the department chair, the student maysubmit a written appeal to the Grade Change Committee via the School of Medicine Registrar with a copy of the appeal to the Associate Dean for Medical Education.
b. The written appeal must state grounds for the grievance.
c. The appeal must be made within 10 days of receiving the decision from the department chair.
d. The Grade Change Committee will then either:/p>
i. Rule that the appeal lacks the merit to warrant a hearing and will uphold the decision of the department chair.
II. Rule that the appeal has the necessary merit for a hearing and will schedule a hearing on the appeal.
e. The Grade Change Committee decision is the final decision for Course grade or Written Evaluation appeals.
II. Faculty Grievance Procedure
1. A faculty member who feels that he/she has been aggrieved as a result of a student appeal proceeding has the right to appear before the Faculty Grievance Committee and present his/her case of the committee.
Policy on Registration/Records/Diploma Holds
Registration Hold
Every student is expected to discharge all obligations to the University as promptly as possible. Students who fail to meet their obligations to the University will not be permitted to register for classes.
Transcript and Diploma Holds
No student or individual duly authorized by the student shall be issued a copy of the student's transcript or receive verification, oral or written, of information contained therein, or be issued a diploma if the student is indebted to the University, the School of Medicine or any affiliated training institutions or agencies and/or if a student is in arrears or default on student loans, and/or if a student fails to participate in required assessment activities. However, requests for verification of enrollment will be fulfilled in circumstances required for student loans as required for use of Title V funds.
Evaluating the Curriculum
A realistic medical curriculum must be flexible, capable of withstanding continuous monitoring, and capable of adjustment to accommodate current changes in medical education brought about by changes in the needs of society. The Curriculum Committee, therefore, with the assistance of special subcommittees and with faculty and student input, continually monitors the curriculum in order to ensure that the goals and objectives of the curriculum and the School of Medicine are achieved.
Advisors
Faculty members from all School of Medicine departments volunteer to serve as advisors to medical students. Advisors counsel students regarding academics or other areas pertinent to students' satisfactory progress in the medical curriculum. They also assist students with such aspects of their clinical years as fourth-year electives, specialty selection, and residency application.
Faculty advisors and medical students are encouraged to meet at least once per semester. Advisors assist personnel in the School of Medicine Office of Student and Career Services in following the academic progress of their advisees.
Student-student advisory systems are at the discretion of the respective classes of the School of Medicine. Incoming first-year students are assigned student mentors in the summer so that they may meet preceding matriculation.
Class Attendance
Absences.
Enrollment in the School of Medicine
obligates students to complete all
assigned course work promptly and to
attend classes on a punctual and regular
basis. Absences, whether excused
or unexcused, do not absolve the student
of these responsibilities.
Grade Penalties for
Excessive Absences. Students
are expected to attend all regular class
sessions. The course or clerkship
director has the prerogative to exact a
grade penalty for excessive
absences. Unsatisfactory class
attendance may be considered adequate
reason for the instructor to refer to
the Student Promotions Committee for
consideration in the promotion process.
Notification of the
Office of Student and Career Services.
Any student who finds it necessary to be
absent from a quiz, examination, or
other required academic experience due
to an emergency situation, illness, or
hospitalization, is required to notify
the Office of Student and Career
Services and the affected
course/clerkship director(s) of the
reason for the absence prior to the
absence or as soon as possible
thereafter. Notification should be
in the form of a phone call, voice
message, or email to both the Office of
Student and Career Services and the
course/clerkship director(s). When
requested, the student will provide
written verification of the reason for
the absence from the treating physician
or other professional to the Director of
Student and Career Services.
Within the guidelines of University of
South Carolina policy, the
course/clerkship director will determine
whether or not an absence from class
shall be excused. Under these
guideline, absences from examinations,
structured laboratory assignments, or
other academic requirements may be made
up at the discretion of the course or
clerkship director.
Lack of Notification.
Any student who does not provide
appropriate notification to the Office
of Student and Career Services
and/or who does not provide written
verification of the reason for the
absence when requested to do so may
forfeit the opportunity to make up
missed examinations and/or other
academic experiences.
Inclement Weather
Policies for M-I and M-II Students.
School of Medicine M-I and M-II classes
are canceled when University of South
Carolina classes are canceled in times
of inclement weather. School of
Medicine M-I and M-II classes begin on a
delayed schedule when University of
South Carolina classes begin on a
delayed schedule in times of inclement
weather.
Inclement Weather and
Holiday Policies for M-III and M-IV
Students. The inclement
weather and holiday policies that have
been developed and approved for M-III
and M-IV students are discussed in the
Student Handbook to Clinical Rotations
and in the Clerkship Director Handbook,
both of which may be accessed through
the Office of Curricular Affairs
Webpage.
Grading System
Credit Grades
The grade point average (GPA) is calculated by dividing the total grade points earned by the hours attempted for credit.
|
Letter Grade |
GPA |
Numerical Grade * |
|
Superior |
A |
4.0 |
90-100 |
|
Above Average |
B+ |
3.5 |
85-89 |
|
B |
3.0 |
80-84 |
|
Satisfactory |
C+ |
2.5 |
75-79 |
|
C |
2.0 |
70-74 |
|
Below Average |
D |
1.0 |
65-69 |
|
Failure |
F |
0.0 |
below 65 |
* Any final numeric grade in a course or clerkship whose first decimal place is calculated to be .5 to .9 shall be rounded to the next whole number, while grades whose first decimal place is calculated to be .0 to .4 should be rounded down to the lower number.
Other Symbols
Other symbols used in the grading system are defined below. These grades do not carry grade points.
|
S |
Satisfactory or passing to be used in evaluating work done on a Pass-Fail basis |
|
U |
Unsatisfactory or failure to be used in evaluating work done on a Pass-Fail basis |
|
W |
Withdrawal passing, or without penalty, from a course or clerkship |
|
WF |
Withdrawal failing, or with penalty, from a course or clerkship |
|
AUD |
Course or clerkship was carried on an audit basis |
|
I |
Incomplete failure to complete some portion of the assigned work in a completed course or clerkship |
|
NR |
No report to be used in the absence of any of the above grades; a temporary mark, to be replaced subsequently by a regular grade, which can be used only when no grade has been assigned |
The faculty of the School of Medicine is committed to the philosophy that satisfactory performance is expected of all students. No single course or clerkship or area of study is deemed to be more important than any other. The required courses and clerkships of the curriculum are all essential for the practice of medicine, regardless of the student's future specialty choice.
Curriculum Accommodations
The School of Medicine will provide reasonable accommodations for students with documented disabilities. Students wishing to request accommodations should make application to the University's Office of Student Disability Services. Once accommodations are approved, the School of Medicine will be notified. The application must be made in a timely manner prior to any coursework for which accommodation is requested. The assistant dean for preclinical curriculum, when indicated, will advise course directors and other pertinent faculty as to the nature and extent of the accommodations to be provided. The School of Medicine, through the subcommittee of the Curriculum Committee, appointed by the chair, retains the right to request additional information, including test results and diagnostic information from a qualified professional, concerning accommodations that extend beyond the following: extended time for written exams, a separate room for exams, and a note taker. Students receiving accommodations will be held to the same technical standards for graduation as other students.
The assistant dean for preclinical curriculum will also assist students in applying to the National Board of Medical Examiners for permission to take the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) under nonstandard conditions.
Leave of Absence, Administrative Leave, and Withdrawal
I. Leave of Absence
A. Request for a Leave of Absence. For a variety of reasons, it may become temporarily impossible for a student to continue a medical education. It is appropriate under such circumstances that the student present all available information and details of the situation through the director of student and career services to the Leave of Absence Committee.
B. Leave of Absence Committee. The Leave of Absence Committee is composed of School of Medicine faculty members (or their faculty designees) and the director of student services who serves, without vote, as secretary to the committee. The committee makes recommendations to the dean regarding the granting of a leave of absence to any student who requests a leave, informs the dean regarding the academic standing of the student at the time of the student's request for a leave, and makes recommendations to the dean regarding a student's return from a leave of absence to full-time student status. According to School of Medicine regulations, a student will be considered as being in good academic standing if he or she had an overall 2.000 grade point average at the conclusion of the prior semester and had passing grades in all courses in the current semester at the time of the request for a leave of absence. A student who leaves the school in good academic standing and returns will not be considered as repeating the semester or year. A student who leaves the school not in good academic standing and returns will be considered as repeating the semester or year. Any student granted a leave of absence is assigned a grade of W in all courses or clerkships in which he or she was enrolled.
In that a leave of absence relieves the student of usual academic responsibilities in the School of Medicine, the Leave of Absence Committee reserves the right to recommend to the dean that a leave of absence be granted with stated conditions, stipulations, and/or contingencies that, in the opinion of the committee, are in the best interest of the student, will serve to document the student's ability to return to full-time student status at the conclusion of the leave of absence, and/or will preserve the integrity of the School of Medicine curriculum.
C. Procedure. Each student who requests a leave of absence will be invited to meet with the Leave of Absence Committee and to present relevant materials for the committee's review, including such statements and professional opinions that the student believes will support a request for a leave of absence. The Leave of Absence Committee will review the statements and professional opinions presented by the student in making its recommendations to the dean about a leave of absence, but such statements or opinions presented by the student are not binding on the Leave of Absence Committee. The student may be accompanied to the committee meeting by one or two advisors of personal choice. The committee meeting is an informal, nonadversarial proceeding. The student may consult with the chosen advisor(s) at any time during the meeting, but the advisor(s) will not be permitted to speak on the student's behalf or to ask questions of committee members.
The committee will inform the dean and the student, in writing, of its recommendation.
D. Decision of the dean. After receiving the recommendation of the Leave of Absence Committee, the dean or his/her designee will invite each student for whom the committee has recommended that a leave of absence not be granted to meet. At this informal and nonadversarial meeting, the student may discuss his or her individual situation and present relevant materials (including a personal statement of a maximum of 10 pages, double-spaced) for the dean's review. The student can be accompanied to this meeting by one or two advisors of personal choice and can consult with the advisor(s), but the advisor(s) will not be permitted to speak on the student's behalf or to ask questions of the dean. The dean will inform each student in writing within 10 working days of this meeting of the decision regarding a leave of absence and of the process of review in the dean's decision.
E. Length of a Leave of Absence. No leave of absence will be granted for a period of time exceeding 12 consecutive months. Any student taking a leave of absence for more than 16 weeks during the third year or fourth year of the medical curriculum will be required to complete the entire third year or fourth year in sequence upon a return to full-time student status.
F. Number of Leaves of Absence. Except under extraordinary circumstances, the School of Medicine will grant only one leave of absence to any student during his or her medical education.
G. Return from Leave of Absence. The Leave of Absence Committee reserves the right to require a meeting with a student prior to his or her return from a leave of absence in order to document the ability to resume full-time student status in the School of Medicine. At this meeting, the student may submit to the Leave of Absence Committee such statements and/or professional opinions that the student believes will support the contention that he or she is prepared to resume full-time student status. The Leave of Absence Committee will review the statements and professional opinions presented by the student in making its recommendations to the dean about the student's return from a leave of absence, but such statements or opinions presented by the student are not binding on the Leave of Absence Committee.
H. Independent Evaluation. The School of Medicine reserves the right to require a student to undergo an independent evaluation, at the School of Medicine's expense, by a physician mutually agreeable to the student and the School of Medicine prior to the student's return from a leave of absence to full-time student status.
I. Review Process. The review process for any decision made by the dean of the School of Medicine can be found in Section V of the "Student Promotions Committee" section.
II. Administrative Leave
During the course of a student's medical education it may become necessary for the student to be placed on administrative leave. A student may be placed on administrative leave due to academic, personal, and/or professional reasons. The associate dean for medical education and academic affairs, in consultation with the chair of the Leave of Absence Committee and the dean, may place a student on administrative leave.
All policies and procedures related to a leave of absence (Section I. A.-I.) will be in effect for any administrative leave.
Any student who is unsuccessful on a first or second attempt at Step 1 of the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) will be placed on administrative leave according to the policies and procedures for promotion and graduation.
III. Withdrawal
Occasionally a student may decide to withdraw from the School of Medicine without an approved leave of absence. All withdrawals will be made in accordance with University of South Carolina policies if the student is to receive a tuition refund and have the proper grades recorded on the transcript. The School of Medicine uses the University schedule for refunds for any student who is dismissed or who withdraws.
A student who withdraws from the School of Medicine and who subsequently wishes to return to school must make application through the Admissions Committee as a new applicant.
Promotion and Graduation
I. United States Medical Licensing Examination
A. Requirements. Students in the School of Medicine are required to pass the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) Steps 1 and 2 prior to graduation. Students are required to pass Step 1 in order to be promoted to the third year and to progress to third-year clerkships. Students are permitted a maximum of three attempts at Step 1 and at Step 2. Failure on the third attempt at Step 1 or Step 2 will render students subject to dismissal from the School of Medicine. Students must be enrolled in the School of Medicine in order to take Step 1 or 2.
B. Timelines. Students must adhere to certain timelines and follow established application procedures in order to allow sufficient time for score reporting prior to various promotion deadlines.
1. Step 1. Second-year students are required to complete applications for Step 1 during the second year in sufficient time to ensure a test date by the end of June and the beginning of third-year clinical clerkships. Students must take Step 1 prior to beginning third-year clinical clerkships.
Any second-year student who is unsuccessful on a first attempt at Step 1 is expected to complete an application in sufficient time to ensure a test date by the conclusion of the second clerkship period of the third year. The student will receive an Incomplete grade for the first clinical clerkship and will be placed on an administrative leave of absence until a second attempt is completed, at which time he or she will re-enter the third year of medical education in the third clerkship period. Upon receipt in the Office of Admissions and Enrollment Services of official notification from the NBME of a passing score on Step 1, the student will receive the letter grade earned in the first clinical clerkship.
Any second-year student who is unsuccessful on a second attempt at Step 1 will immediately be placed on an administrative leave of absence for the remainder of that academic year in order to prepare for the third and final administration of Step 1 and is expected to complete an application in sufficient time to ensure a test date and score reporting by the beginning of the first third-year clerkship period of the next academic year. In the interim, the student will not be permitted to progress further in the third year of medical education. The student will not earn academic credit for the first clinical clerkship; a grade of W will replace the Incomplete grade.
Any student who is successful on a third attempt at Step 1 will begin third-year clerkships in the first clerkship period of the subsequent academic year and is required to complete the entire third year in sequence.
2. Step 2. Fourth-year students are expected to complete applications for Step 2 Clinical Knowledge (CK) and Clinical Skills (CS) in sufficient time to ensure test dates by the end of rotation 6 in December.
Any fourth-year student who is unsuccessful on a first or second attempt at Step 2 CK and/or CS is expected to complete an application in sufficient time to ensure a test date that will allow sufficient time for the score to be reported by May 15. This date allows time for academic reporting to be complete for the May graduation from the School of Medicine.
II. Requirements for Promotion
A. Academic Progress. In order to be promoted to the next academic year or to be permitted to continue to the next academic semester, a student must be recommended for promotion or continuation to the dean by the Student Promotions Committee. A student should maintain at least a 2.000 grade point average in order to be promoted to the next academic year or permitted to continue to the next academic semester. A student receiving less than a 2.000 grade point average in an academic semester or academic year or less than a 2.000 cumulative grade point average is subject to dismissal.
1. Repeat of Course Failed. The grade of F is used to denote failure in a course or clerkship; a student receiving a grade of F in one or more courses or clerkships is subject to dismissal. A student receiving an F grade in a course or clerkship may be permitted by the dean, in consultation with the Student Promotions Committee, to repeat the course or clerkship. A student permitted to repeat a clinical clerkship must repeat the clerkship at the University of South Carolina School of Medicine; a student permitted to repeat a preclinical course may repeat the course at another medical school approved by the course director and the assistant dean for preclinical curriculum. If the student fails to achieve a C or better grade in the repeated course or clerkship, the student will be subject to dismissal from the School of Medicine or will be required to repeat the academic year, at the discretion of the dean in consultation with the Student Promotions Committee.
Upon satisfactory completion of the repeated course or clerkship, both the original F grade and the grade received in the repeated course or clerkship will be recorded on the student's transcript. Grade points and credit hours for both grades will be calculated into the cumulative grade point average which is used for promotion decisions and in the determination of class rank.
In the case of a continuing course (Biochemistry, Pathology), if a student receives an F grade in the first semester and the student is permitted by the dean, in consultation with the Student Promotions Committee, to continue to the next semester, the student will be required to attend classes in that course during the second semester and take all course examinations on a Pass-Fail basis and then repeat the entire course.
2. Repeated Semester/Year. A student will not usually be permitted to repeat more than one academic semester or academic year. A student who is repeating the semester or year must receive a grade of C or better in repeated courses or clerkships in order to be promoted to the next academic year or permitted to continue to the next academic semester. A student who fails to receive a grade of C or better in repeated courses or clerkships is subject to dismissal.
If a student is required to repeat an academic semester or academic year, grade points and credit hours from the original semester or year will not be calculated into the cumulative grade point average for the purpose of promotions decisions. For all other purposes, grade points and credit hours from the original academic semester or academic year will be calculated into the cumulative grade point average.
3. Unsatisfactory Grade in Personal and Professional Conduct. A student who receives an Unsatisfactory grade in the personal and professional conduct portion of a third- or fourth-year clerkship evaluation will receive an Incomplete grade in that clerkship. The student will not be permitted to continue in other clerkships but will be required to repeat the clerkship or, alternately, to repeat the component(s) of the clerkship identified as necessary by the clerkship director. If a second Unsatisfactory grade is received in the personal and professional conduct portion of the professional evaluation in the repeat clerkship, then the student will be subject to dismissal. If the student receives exemplary or effective grades in personal and professional conduct and a C or higher letter grade in the repeat clerkship, he or she will be permitted to continue in the third or fourth year. Any additional Unsatisfactory grades in personal and professional conduct during the third year or during the fourth year will render the student subject to dismissal.
B. Personal and Professional Conduct. Student progress is based upon professional performance which includes both cognitive mastery of the basic and clinical sciences and personal and professional conduct that reflects the high standards of moral and ethical behavior and judgment necessary for professional practice as a physician. Factors which could result in a student's suspension or dismissal from the School of Medicine, regardless of grades in basic science course work and clinical clerkships and electives, include, but are not limited to, violations of the School of Medicine Policy on Evaluation of Personal and Professional Conduct, violations of University regulations as described in the Carolina Community, or conviction of a criminal offense.
III. Requirements for Graduation
Upon recommendation by the School of Medicine faculty, the University of South Carolina will confer the degree of Doctor of Medicine upon candidates who have:
A. attained the School's educational objectives as evidenced by satisfactory completion of prescribed basic science courses and clinical clerkships and electives and acquisition of all required clinical skills;
B. passed Steps 1 and 2 of the USMLE;
C. completed the clinical skills attainment document;
D. attended the University of South Carolina School of Medicine on a full-time basis for a minimum of two years; and
E. discharged all financial obligations to the School of Medicine and to the University.
In order to graduate in the May commencement ceremony, fourth-year students must complete successfully all academic requirements by May 31.
Student Promotions Committee
I. Academic Review Committee
The Academic Review Committee, composed of the chair of the Student Promotions Committee and faculty members who are not department chairs, meets at the end of each semester and at other times, as necessary, with each student who is subject to dismissal based upon School of Medicine academic regulations. The committee develops recommendations for consideration by the Student Promotions Committee regarding the student's continued enrollment and/or academic progress in the School of Medicine.
Each student who is subject to dismissal will be invited to meet with committee members in order to discuss his or her individual situation and to present relevant materials for the committee's review. The student may be accompanied to the committee meeting by one or two advisors of personal choice. The committee meeting is an informal, nonadversarial proceeding. The student may consult with the advisor(s) at any time during the meeting, but the advisor(s) will not be permitted to speak on the student's behalf or to ask questions of committee members.
Each student who is subject to dismissal has the right to submit, prior to the committee meeting, relevant materials, including copies of a personal statement (maximum 10 pages, double-spaced), for review by the Academic Review Committee and the Student Promotions Committee.
II. Student Promotions Committee
The Student Promotions Committee, acting for the faculty, makes recommendations to the dean regarding each student's continued enrollment and/or academic progress in the School of Medicine, including continuation to the next academic semester, promotion to the next academic year, suspension, dismissal, or any variation thereof that in the opinion of the committee is appropriate. Voting members of the committee include those faculty members who are the chairs of School of Medicine departments (or their designees) and two faculty members elected by the Faculty Representation Committee. Voting committee members will elect the chair of the Student Promotions Committee at the first meeting of each academic year. The associate dean for medical education and academic affairs will serve, without vote, as executive secretary to the committee.
The Student Promotions Committee will receive information of various types, including, but not limited to, grades, evaluations, narrative comments from course and clerkship directors, and recommendations from members of the Academic Review Committee and/or from personnel in the Office of Medical Education and Academic Affairs, and, where indicated, opinions from other sources, including, but not limited to, faculty members, personnel at School of Medicine-affiliated hospitals, consultants, and representatives of relevant professional organizations.
The Student Promotions Committee reserves the right, in its deliberations about recommendations to the dean, to consider all relevant information that bears on a student's fitness to become a physician. All recommendations are made by the Student Promotions Committee to the dean, who will have the final decision within the School of Medicine.
The Student Promotions Committee will meet at the conclusion of each semester and, as necessary, at other times during the year. Criteria for continued enrollment and academic progress will be reviewed regularly. The committee will inform the dean and the student, in writing, of its recommendations.
III. Academic Alternatives
The Student Promotions Committee may recommend to the dean any of the following academic alternatives:
A. permitting the student to continue to the next academic semester;
B. promoting the student to the next academic year;
C. promoting the student to the next academic year, contingent upon satisfactory completion of all academic deficiencies and contingent upon re-review by the committee;
D. requiring the student to repeat successfully a course, a clerkship, an elective, the academic semester, or the academic year;
E. suspending the student from the School of Medicine for a specified period of time, up to a maximum of one calendar year1;1
F. dismissing the student from the School of Medicine; or
G. a combination of any of the above-mentioned academic alternatives.
H. other sanctions deemed educationally beneficial to the student.
IV. Decision of the Dean
After receiving the recommendations of the Student Promotions Committee, the dean will invite each student for whom the Student Promotions Committee has recommended any academic alternative other than A or B (above) to meet. At this informal and nonadversarial meeting, the student may discuss his or her individual situation and present relevant materials (including a personal statement of a maximum of 10 pages, double-spaced) for the dean's review. The student may be accompanied to this meeting by one or two advisors of personal choice and may consult with the advisor(s), but the advisor(s) will not be permitted to speak on the student's behalf or to ask questions of the dean. The dean will inform each student, in writing, within 10 working days of this meeting of the dean's decision and of the process of review of the dean's decision.
In the case of the dismissal of a first- or second-year student, a first- or second-year student will be permitted to remain enrolled in first- and second-year courses during the review process, but, if the review process has not been completed by the commencement of the third year, a second-year student will not be permitted to begin the third year until the outcome of the review process has been determined.
In the case of the dismissal of a third- or fourth-year student, notwithstanding the student's right to a review of the dean's decision, the decision of the dean is effective with the date of the dean's letter informing the student of dismissal. A third- or fourth-year student who has been dismissed from the School of Medicine will not be permitted to continue to engage in patient care activities, will not be permitted to remain enrolled in clinical clerkships or electives, and will not be considered to be enrolled in the School of Medicine.
A student will not receive grades in any courses completed during the period of the review process and will receive any refund of tuition and fee payments according to the schedules published by the University of South Carolina.
V. Review Process
A final request for review may be made to the president of the University of South Carolina of any decision made by the dean of the School of Medicine. This request for review must be made, in writing, within 10 working days of the student's receipt of the dean's decision.
During the review process, the student will be invited to submit to the president a personal statement (maximum 10 pages, double-spaced) in which the grounds for the request for review are explained. There will be four possible grounds for a request for review: (1) that the decision of the dean is not supported by substantial evidence; (2) that a procedural violation has occurred that has prejudiced the dean's deliberations; (3) that, when the record is reviewed as a whole, the decision of the dean is punitive rather than academically appropriate; and/or (4) that the dean's decision is an arbitrary and capricious one.
The president can reverse, affirm, or modify the dean's decision. Any modification of the dean's decision by the president cannot require greater remedial effort on the part of the student than that required by the dean's original decision regarding an academic alternative.
Ideally, the outcome of the president's review will be communicated to the student, in writing, within 30 days of the date of receipt of the request for a review. The president's review will consist of an assessment of the student's existing record in the School of Medicine, with no new information being provided by the student or by the School of Medicine.
_______________________________
1 At the end of the period of suspension, the student will submit to the Student Promotions Committee such statements and/or professional opinions believed to support the contention that the reasons for suspension have been resolved and that he or she is capable of returning to full-time student status. The Student Promotions Committee will review the statements and professional opinions presented in making its recommendations to the dean about the return of the student to full-time student status, but such statements or opinions presented are not binding on the Student Promotions Committee.
The School of Medicine reserves the right to require a student seeking to return to full-time student status from a period of suspension to undergo an independent evaluation, at the School of Medicine's expense, by a physician mutually agreeable to the student and to the School of Medicine. The report from this independent evaluation will be submitted to the Student Promotions Committee for its review prior to its making its recommendation to the dean about a student's return to full-time status, but the statements or opinions presented in this report are not binding on the committee.
Following receipt of a recommendation from the Student Promotions Committee that a student not be permitted to return to full-time status after a period of suspension, the dean will invite the student to meet. At this informal and nonadversarial meeting, the student may discuss his or her individual situation and present relevant materials, including a personal statement (maximum 10 pages, double spaced) for the dean's review. The student may be accompanied to this meeting by one or two advisors of personal choice and may consult with the advisor(s), but the advisor(s) will not be permitted to speak on the student's behalf or to ask questions of the dean. The dean will inform each student, in writing, within 10 working days of this meeting of the decision and of the process of review.