Skip to Content

Arnold School of Public Health


Study finds new non-exercise fitness test serves as reliable predictor of stroke for whites but not blacks

June 11, 2018 | Erin Bluvas, bluvase@sc.edu

Research led by exercise science assistant professor Xuemei Sui has revealed racial differences in the usefulness of a new fitness measure in predicting the risk of stroke. The study was published in Mayo Clinic Proceedings.

After adjusting for stroke risk factors and physical functioning, the risk of incident stroke was 36 percent lower for whites with mid-range cardiorespiratory fitness and 63 percent lower for whites with the highest fitness levels. The authors found no association between cardiorespiratory fitness and stroke risk within the black population.

Stroke is the fifth leading cause of death in the United States and the second-leading cause of death globally. Identifying modifiable factors such as cardiorespiratory fitness, which has been associated with cardiovascular disease, has important public health significance for stroke prevention.

“In the U.S., risk of having a first stroke is nearly twice as high for blacks than for whites,” says Sui. “Therefore, the primary prevention of stroke is particularly important in the black population.”

The non-exercise estimated cardiorespiratory fitness (eCRF) method has shown promise in its ability to predict risk factors for morbidity and mortality, though its usefulness in predicting stroke incidence is not yet clear—especially among African Americans. The method estimates fitness using a simple and easily administered non-exercise tool that can even be applied to previously collected data.

Sui and others have confirmed non-exercise eCRF’s accuracy in predicting risk factors for cardiovascular disease as well as cancer mortality. The present study expanded the applications of this method to predicting stroke while also comparing its utility by race. 

Using data from the Reasons for Geographic and Racial Differences in Stroke study, the researchers examined data from more than 24,000 participants who were followed from enrollment (between 2003 and 2007) through March of 2016. Nearly 40 percent of the participants were African Americans, more than 54 percent were women, and the average participant age was 64.6 years. None of the participants had experienced a stroke prior to joining the study.

Over an average of eight years of follow-up during the study period, 945 strokes incidents occurred (377 in black participants and 568 in white participants). The authors found that the association between non-exercise eCRF and stroke risk differed significantly by race, with a strong association for white participants and no association found for black participants. Associations for women versus men did not differ.

“We found that non-exercise eCRF was a strong independent predictor of future stroke for whites but not for blacks, while results were similar for men and women,” says Sui. “This method is a useful predictor of stroke in whites, but the lack of an overall association between eCRF and stroke risk in blacks suggests that assessment of eCRF in blacks may not be helpful in primary stroke prevention.”

Despite the lack of association between non-exercise eCRF and stroke risk in the African American population in the present study, the authors recommend, as they have proposed previously alongside the American Heart Association, that CRF be recognized as an important marker of cardiovascular health. Accordingly, it should be included in routine clinical assessments.

“Non-exercise eCRF might provide reasonably accurate estimates for initial CRF screening for stroke prevention,” Sui says. “Considering the higher incidence of stroke among blacks and the potentially protective effect of higher level eCRF in older blacks, greater efforts directed at understanding CRF in blacks are needed.”  

This research project was supported by a cooperative agreement U01 NS041588 from the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, National Institute of Health, Department of Health and Human Services.


Related:

Researchers use non-exercise test to confirm link between cardiorespiratory fitness and reduced cancer mortality in U.S. population

Researchers author scientific statement for American Heart Association, recommending fitness become clinical vital sign

Arnold School researchers find higher fitness levels can delay elevated levels of cholesterol for men by 15 years

Xuemei Sui receives 2015 Breakthrough Star award from the Office of the VP for Research

University of South Carolina study finds Body Mass Index may no longer be relevant indicator of health