Evan Faulkenbury: If you’ve been listening to this podcast for a while, you’ve heard about the Great Biscuit Rebellion of 1852, students engaged in dueling and lots of other shenanigans that students who attended South Carolina College got into during the 19th century.
Welcome to Remembering the Days, where we explore the stories and talk with the people who are part of the rich history of the University of South Carolina. I’m Evan Faulkenbury, and on this episode, Chris Horn and I are revisiting a lesser-known rowdy event in Carolina’s history that had major consequences: the Guard House Riot of 1856. In February of that year, a series of confrontations between college students and Columbia’s police nearly led to a mass slaughter.
Chris and I invited Dr. Robert Elder onto the show to tell us more. Bob is a professor of history at Baylor University who has published extensively about South Carolina, including a recent biography of John C. Calhoun. Last year, he published an essay in the Journal of Southern History about the Guard House Riot of 1856. We began by asking Dr. Elder to tell us the story of what exactly happened.
Chris Horn: There's probably no such thing as the two-minute elevator speech on what happened over the course of those couple of days, but give us a synopsis of what transpired with the Guard House Riot.
Bob Elder: So it starts with a student named Edward Niles, who's from Camden, and Niles and a couple of his friends are somewhere in downtown Columbia having a drink on Monday night, that's February 18th, 1856. They're walking back to campus, and they pass the guardhouse, which, at that time, is on the corner of Washington and Richardson. Now, this is Washington and Main Street. I think it's a city building or an office building now of some kind, but it was a guardhouse, and there was a jail on that same corner at the time. As they're walking past, the city guard is coming out and the city guard is led by a man named John Burdell. And Edward Niles, for some reason, starts antagonizing Burdell, and we don't know exactly why, but Burdell seems to have, maybe, arrested his brother or done something to Nile's brother at some point.
He starts antagonizing Burdell, and Burdell takes out a club, essentially, and just knocks Niles down right in the street; knocks him unconscious. Burdell and some of the patrolmen who are with him start dragging Burdell back to the guardhouse. Meanwhile, the other students who are with Niles run back to campus, and they start yelling this, this call, "College! College!" Or, "The college! The college!," which, a couple of the histories of South Carolina College during this period mentioned this as sort of something that you would yell when you were trying to rouse the student body, right? You were trying to get everybody to come out. It was the sort of thing, now you'd yell it at a football game, right? But then it was sort of like, "Something has happened. We all need to come alive!" And so dozens of students come out, they head back to the guardhouse, and there's conflicting accounts of what happens, but it seems somehow they break into the guardhouse and bust Edwin Niles out and start going back towards campus.
Now, the president of the college at this time, who's brand new, Charles McKay, he's only been in office a few weeks, he does not have a good handle on the student body. James Henley Thornwell had been famous for his ability to sort of handle the students, and McKay is coming in after Thornwell and just doesn't have the same ability. McKay heads to the guardhouse to find out what happened, and as he's at the guardhouse, the students, or a few students led by John Charles McClenaghan, burst back into the guardhouse. Now, evidently, they decided that they just needed revenge on John Burdell. They burst back into the guardhouse, and Burdell and his patrolmen quickly beat the tar out of them and force them back out of the guardhouse. The city's mayor, who was there when the students break back in, calls out the militia, and it sort of subsides at that point for the evening because everybody sort of goes to their corners, the students go back to campus.
McKay at this point realizes that this could potentially be a crisis. He begins working with the mayor to try to come up with some sort of compromise that would work because the students, they still want revenge on Burdell. And McKay kind of takes the side of the students at first and assumes that Burdell did something wrong, and the mayor, evidently, refuses to agree with that and kind of takes Burdell's side, which shows you instantly the sort of town/gown divide that's developing.
So the next morning, McKay calls a faculty meeting, and it's fascinating because you can read the minutes of this meeting in the South Caroliniana Library. And as you're reading the minutes of the meeting, there's sort of a break, and what happens at that break is that in the middle of the meeting, something happens, and McKay and the faculty hear students start running past the meeting they're in and going somewhere.
And what had happened is that John Charles McClenaghan and a friend had gone back out that morning looking for John Burdell. They had found him, they had ambushed him. They had gotten beaten again by Burdell and his men, and they had come back to campus and raised the students again, and they've armed themselves because, of course, South Carolina College at this point still has sort of a military aspect to it, so there's guns on campus. They arm themselves, and they're running back to the location of the guardhouse. They're running a few blocks north from campus on what was then Richardson Street, now Main Street. They're probably on Main Street. At the same time, the mayor has now called out the city militia, and so what develops when McKay and the faculty finally get there is there is roughly a hundred students armed on one side of the street facing what some observers say was about 200, a mixture of citizens and the city militia, also armed.
There's accounts from people who were there who say this could have developed, at an instant, into a bloodbath. It was just so close to being a catastrophe. And Charles McKay has no — the students are not listening to him. They do not listen to him, but at some point during all this, somebody realizes that the person who could control them is James Henley Thornwell. Thornwell is no longer president of the college, but he is now a professor at Columbia Theological Seminary, there in Columbia. And somebody literally runs and interrupts him during a lecture and says, "You have got to get downtown." Thornwell runs downtown. Thornwell comes and puts himself right into the middle of this, right into the middle of these two sides, and he addresses the students and says, "I understand why you're angry. I get it, but this is not the way to solve it. We need to talk about this. I'll listen to you. Let's go back to the college chapel and talk about this. And if we decide that violence really is the only way to solve this, then I will come back, and I'll fight with you, and I'll die in your midst," which is, you know, kind of a remarkable thing for a Presbyterian pastor to say.
But the students listen to Thornwell. The students go back to the chapel, and Thornwell is able to talk them into accepting a sort of deal, essentially an arbitration, a sort of court of honor where prominent men from the state will hear both sides and decide who should apologize, essentially the same sort of mechanism that resolved duels in lots of ways. And the people that come with Thornwell to address the students at that time are incredibly prominent people in the state, so people like William C. Preston, who had been a United States senator, he'd been president of the college, he'd been a prominent person in the nullification crisis 25 years earlier. At that point, the students had to decide if they were willing to defy that level of authority, and they decided not to. So the immediate crisis sort of ends there, but then there's weeks and weeks of argument about who's to blame and those sorts of things. But that was the sort of end of, at least, the possibility of real bloodshed.
So I think the quickest way to say it is this is, from a 30,000-foot perspective, this is one of the largest college riots of the 19th century. It involves hundreds of people, certainly dozens of students from South Carolina College. It happens in February, mid-February of 1856. And since Columbia, of course, is the capital as well as where South Carolina College is, it sort of draws into it a lot of characters who are important, not only in the college's history, but in South Carolina's history and, in the end, in American history.
Evan Faulkenbury: After hearing the play-by-play of what happened and who was involved in the 1856 Guard House Riot, Chris and I wanted to know more about the motivations of those South Carolina College students. Turns out, according to Dr. Elder, much of it had to do with their personal sense of honor.
Bob Elder: And then you come on this story of students at South Carolina College in 1856, and throughout this whole episode, what the students are really sort of acting on is this sense that their honor was violated and that they need, in some way, to either take revenge for that, or that somebody has to acknowledge that their honor was violated, and there needs to be some sort of process, or some sort of recompense for that happening. It's such a clear example of the way that, sort of, the first recourse frequently for white, Southern men of a certain age during the 1850s, when they felt their honor had been violated, was violence. That was seen as sort of an appropriate response, right?
Now, it's not like this has completely gone away. When I was in school at that other place in South Carolina, it's still if somebody insulted your mother, that those were still fighting words. That's still around, but I think this was just an incredibly sort of clear case of it because so many people tried to stop them over, and over, and over again, and they simply keep going back to this idea that the correct response when your honor is questioned or violated is to respond with some sort of violence, that you knock the guy down, you grab your guns and run out to the street to face the city militia and those sorts of things. And so for me, as a historian, the story is interesting in its own right, but also it's interesting as a sort of test case showing these versions of honor were still around and still very, very powerful in 1856, which in turn may help to explain what happens four years later in 1860.
That is really what I try to argue is that part of what you're seeing in this whole episode is there is something unique, even within a Southern context, about South Carolina and the culture, especially, I think, among the elite slave-holding class, which is primarily, at least in the 1850s, where the students from South Carolina College would've been drawn from. I mean, these are the state's elite.
Evan Faulkenbury: And the state’s elite wanted some control over their sons’ educations. Trying to understand the context of the 1856 Guard House Riot, we asked Dr. Elder about what made South Carolina College unique during this era.
Bob Elder: The college by 1856 has been around for decades, since the early 19th century. And it is one of the elite universities, certainly in the South, and many people in the South see it as an alternative to all the elite universities in the North. Part of its identity was as a place where the elite of South Carolina could be educated so they didn't have to go to — in an era when differences over slavery are starting to matter a lot more — so that they didn't have to go to northern universities like Princeton or Yale. I mean, South Carolina elites of a previous generation had mostly done that. I mean, people like John C. Calhoun had gone to places like Yale around the turn of the century.
South Carolina has the largest concentration of large slaveholders in the entire South at this point, just by numbers. The only place that can really come close to it is Mississippi and the Mississippi Delta area in the 1850s. So these are very, very wealthy — many of them — are very, very wealthy people.
And at the same time that you have that, you have the growth, in places like Columbia, of a true urban middle class in the South. And these, by and large, were people in work that might relate in some way to slavery, or cotton, and rice and those sorts of things. But really, these are the sort of urban professionals that you would've found in many cities in the North. These are lawyers, and manufacturers, and merchants, and shop owners and people like this. And, you know, they go to church on Sunday, they live orderly lives, they record their purchases in books, and they have sort of an approach to life that's different than the planter class. One of the things I try to show in the article is that they really had established in Columbia off the bounds of the campus, around the campus, they had tried to establish a very middle-class sort of society.
Evan Faulkenbury: And it’s this generation — the sons of the planter class — that went up against the city’s guards and militia, who were not of the elite class but more middle-class. The Guard House Riot of 1856 tested the limits of what the state’s young elite could — and could not — get away with.
Bob Elder: I mean, the two sides that sort of develop are people from this urban middle class who sort of blame the students and say, "Look, the rule of law has to hold for everybody." And really what they're attacking, in a lot of ways there, is the sort of culture of honor that says if you're insulted, the law goes out the window and you're able to do what you need to do to restore your sense of yourself. And then people who defend the students essentially and say, "Look, jealousy of your honor is not a bad thing. We shouldn't squelch this in students. This is actually a valuable response, and it's understandable." After all, one of them is put in this guardhouse where the usual people that went into that guardhouse were poor white people and urban slaves from Columbia who'd been caught out without permission, and so to put a young white man in that guardhouse was an insult to him and to all of them, so this is sort of understandable.
Evan Faulkenbury: We wanted to know from Dr. Elder, beyond just this being an interesting, little-known story in South Carolina’s long history, why the Guard House Riot of 1856 is important. We can look back on history and see that a lot was about to happen between 1856 and 1860, when South Carolina seceded and the Civil War began. Preston Brooks, for example, who had attended South Carolina College, caned Sen. Charles Sumner nearly to death in the Capital just a few months after this riot. And Preston Brooks did so because he felt that his personal honor had been insulted — the same reason why the South Carolina College students had rioted. So, big picture, why does this story matter?
Bob Elder: And so in some ways, the riot gives us a way to study how these things happened and how students became habituated to certain ways of responding, in certain situations, that you see play out, not only in the U.S. Senate, but maybe in some ways in 1860 as well. I think that's important to keep in mind. It doesn't, in any way, mean that there weren't other great things going on at South Carolina College. And certainly, I don't mean to say that the Civil War was the fault of South Carolina College, but it is just to say that I do think there was something unique about it in terms of its cultural function within South Carolina and the uniqueness of South Carolina itself at that period. And all those things together, I think, helped to explain why it is South Carolina that secedes first in 1860.
In an important way, the Guard House Riot of 1856, while certainly not a direct cause of the Civil War, raised the blood pressure of the planter class’s young men at South Carolina College who couldn’t stand any insult to their honor without paying it back with violence. Five years later, they’d be marching to war for the Confederacy.
That’s all for this episode of Remembering the Days. Thanks to Dr. Robert Elder for joining us. On our next episode, Chris and I are going to sit down and have a conversation with Dr. Henrie Monteith Treadwell, who desegregated the University of South Carolina in 1963. Just this past year she published her first memoir with the University of South Carolina Press. Hope to see you then.